The Most Dangerous Investment Risk Nobody Talks About


Recently, something interesting happened.

One of my clients discussed her portfolio with a friend.
The friend confidently suggested:

“Why is so much money lying in emergency funds? Just keep 2.5 lakh in the bank. Move the rest to long-term investments. Returns will be higher.”

Soon after, I received this message:

“Hi Nilesh,
I’m not happy with the return I’m getting. It’s very less.
Is there anything we can do?
I’m interested in Coin as well — it’s giving good returns.”

Now pause here.

Nothing had changed in her goals.
Nothing had changed in her financial plan.
Nothing had changed in the structure we built.

Only one thing changed.

Comparison.

_____________________________________________________________________________________

Social Comparison Risk

We talk about market risk.
We talk about inflation risk.
We talk about liquidity risk.

But rarely do we talk about social comparison risk.

This is the risk of doubting a well-structured financial plan because someone else’s numbers look better.

And this risk silently destroys discipline. 

The Emergency Fund Debate

Let’s understand the logic.

To a return-chasing investor, emergency money looks “idle.”

To a planner, emergency money is protection.

It prevents:

  • Forced redemption during market falls

  • Taking loans at the wrong time

  • Emotional panic selling

  • Breaking long-term compounding

Emergency funds are not meant to generate returns.

They are meant to protect your ability to stay invested.

That is their job.

If your house insurance does not “give returns,” do you cancel it?

Of course not.

But in investing, we often forget this logic.

The Real Issue Was Not Returns

When someone says,
“Returns are less,”

What they often mean is,
“Someone else is earning more.”

There is a difference.

If your financial plan requires 11–12% CAGR and you are earning 13%, the plan is working.

But if your friend earned 22% in a thematic fund last year, suddenly 13% feels small.

This is not math.
This is psychology.

The Coin & FOMO Effect

Platforms like Coin or direct investing apps show high-performing funds prominently.

But they don’t show:

  • Volatility

  • Downside risk

  • Suitability

  • Goal alignment

  • Emotional tolerance

High return always travels with high fluctuation.

And fluctuation is acceptable only when:

  1. Your financial capacity allows it.

  2. Your emotional stability supports it.

Without these two, higher return becomes higher regret.

Why This Matters

Investing is not a competition.

It is not about beating friends.
It is not about winning short-term discussions.
It is not about having the highest number in the group.

It is about reaching your goals with stability.

When comparison enters, discipline exits.

And when discipline exits, compounding suffers.

The Question I Ask

Whenever comparison arises, I ask:

“Are we investing for excitement or for certainty?”

There is nothing wrong with taking higher risk —
as long as it aligns with your plan, capacity, and temperament.

But changing strategy because someone else earned more is not strategy.

It is reaction.

A Simple Truth

Someone will always earn more than you in any given year.

And someone will always lose more than you.

The goal is not to be the highest return investor.

The goal is to be the most consistent one.

Final Thought

Markets don’t usually damage portfolios.

Impatience does.

Comparison does.

And sometimes, well-meaning friends do.

But a structured financial plan, built around your goals — not someone else’s returns — is what creates long-term wealth.

Always remember:

The best portfolio is not the one that looks impressive in conversation.

It is the one that survives cycles.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Turning Market Volatility into Opportunity

Image
Today’s world feels fast, uncertain, and noisy. News around global trade tensions, especially between the US and Asia, and ongoing issues in the Middle East can easily create fear in investors’ minds. But here’s the reality — this noise is where real opportunities are created. India Story is Still Strong While global markets are facing challenges like rising costs and supply chain changes, India continues to stand strong. Even now, India’s growth is expected to be around 6.6% to 6.9% , which is very healthy. Yes, foreign investors may move money in and out due to global situations. But our domestic growth story is intact : Infrastructure spending is increasing Manufacturing is growing Rural consumption is improving 👉 This is what keeps India stable. Important Truth About Investing Markets don’t reward you when everything looks perfect. They reward you when: You stay invested during uncertainty You don’t panic when others are exiting Real wealth is created du...
Read more

Wealth Is Built Slowly, Lost Quickly

Image
  A tragedy from Maharashtra has been on my mind for the last few days. According to preliminary reports, Yogesh Balasaheb Patil , a school principal from Hattij village in Barshi taluka of Solapur district, along with his wife and their two children, tragically lost their lives. Initial investigations have suggested that substantial losses in stock market investments had allegedly left him burdened with debts estimated at nearly ₹1.80 crore . As the news spread, many stories began circulating. Some spoke of assets being sold. Others spoke of mounting financial pressure. As with any such incident, the complete facts will emerge only through a thorough investigation. But when I read the news, I did not think about the stock market. I thought about a father. A husband. A family. And I wondered what must have been going through his mind in those final days. How does a person reach a point where the burden feels heavier than hope? As a Certified Financial Planner, I have spent years di...
Read more

Achieving Financial Freedom & Finding the Way of Life

Image
In the world of financial planning, success is often measured in numbers—assets, returns, and net worth. But true success goes beyond wealth; it’s about living life on your own terms. This is the story of Abhijeet Chitriv, a man who not only achieved financial freedom but also discovered the essence of life by staying focused on his dreams and delegating financial decisions to a structured plan. The Beginning: Setting the Foundation I first met Abhijeet in 2012 at Symantec. He approached me with a simple yet profound question: “How am I doing compared to my peers, and what more can be done to optimize my finances?” My answer was straightforward—finance is deeply personal. There’s no one-size-fits-all approach because everything depends on your values, principles, and family choices. The real question was: What do you want from life? Once that was clear, we could optimize his financial plan accordingly. From Financial Goals to Life Goals We began by identifying his life goals, gatherin...
Read more